home/categories/education/evoscientist-evoskills-skills-paper-rebuttal-skill-md
educationdocumentation

paper-rebuttal

Guides writing effective rebuttals after receiving peer review feedback. Covers review diagnosis (score-driven color-coding), response strategy (champion identification, common-theme consolidation), tactical writing (18 rules), and counterintuitive rebuttal principles. Use when: user received reviewer scores/comments, needs to write a rebuttal or author response, wants to respond to specific criticism (e.g. 'limited novelty', 'missing baselines'), mentions 'rebuttal', 'reviewer comments', 'author response', or 'respond to reviewers'. Do NOT use for pre-submission self-review (use paper-review instead).

EvoScientist
maintainer
EvoScientist
업데이트됨 3/17/2026
스타
140
포크
16
quick start

Installation and usage

Guides writing effective rebuttals after receiving peer review feedback. Covers review diagnosis (score-driven color-coding), response strategy (champion identification, common-theme consolidation), tactical writing (18 rules), and counterintuitive rebuttal principles. Use when: user received reviewer scores/comments, needs to write a rebuttal or author response, wants to respond to specific criticism (e.g. 'limited novelty', 'missing baselines'), mentions 'rebuttal', 'reviewer comments', 'author response', or 'respond to reviewers'. Do NOT use for pre-submission self-review (use paper-review instead).

설치
$ install --globalskills.sh
사용법

설치 후 터미널에서 다음 명령을 실행하여 이 스킬을 사용할 수 있습니다:

skills use paper-rebuttal